Field report

The Return Has a Second Total

The tax result gets the bold type. The work required to produce it is printed much farther back.

Near the back of the 2025 Form 1040 instructions, the IRS prints a total that will never appear on the refund screen. Across all individual filers, it estimates 12 hours of pre-filing and filing work and $290 in out-of-pocket cost. For nonbusiness filers, the estimate is eight hours and $160; for business filers, it is 21 hours and $610.

Most conversations about a tax return revolve around the result: money owed, money refunded, or the welcome zero between them. The burden table asks readers to look at the production cost of that result. Somebody had to find the forms, keep the records, answer the software prompts, check the entries, submit the return, and perhaps pay for help. None of that changes the legal tax calculation, but it changes what filing requires from the person doing it.

Eight hours is not an appointment

The IRS classifies 71 percent of the returns in its estimate as nonbusiness and 29 percent as business. For this purpose, a business return includes Schedule C, E, or F or Form 2106, while a return without those forms is counted as nonbusiness. That line is easy to miss and important to keep. “Nonbusiness” does not mean uncomplicated, and the eight-hour average is not a promise that a particular filer will be finished by dinner.

A household with two wage statements and a standard deduction is not doing the same job as one reporting investment sales, several credits, or a change in family circumstances, even if both land in the nonbusiness group. Preparation method matters too. A person may file alone, use software, visit a volunteer site, or pay a professional. The IRS number is an average across those arrangements, not a stopwatch aimed at a supposedly normal taxpayer.

What the government is asking for

The active federal information-collection record describes the transaction without much romance. Individuals use the return and its associated forms to report income and compute the correct tax liability. The IRS uses the information to calculate that liability and determine whether claimed items are allowable.

That purpose is legitimate and consequential. A tax system cannot administer credits, deductions, payments, and liability without collecting facts that allow the calculation to be checked. The existence of paperwork therefore does not prove that the work is pointless. It does mean the filing burden should be examined as part of the system rather than treated as a private hobby that millions of people happen to schedule in the same season.

The receipt behind the return

For the nonbusiness group, the IRS divides the eight-hour estimate into four parts: three hours of recordkeeping, one hour of tax planning, three hours to complete and submit the return, and one hour of other pre-filing and filing work. The separate $160 estimate covers expenses such as preparation and submission fees, postage, copying, and tax software.

2025 nonbusiness activityIRS average
Recordkeeping3 hours
Tax planning1 hour
Completion and submission3 hours
Other pre-filing and filing work1 hour
Total time8 hours
Out-of-pocket cost, kept separate$160

The table is more useful when it is read as a receipt rather than a prediction. It names different kinds of work, keeps time separate from cash, and makes no attempt to assign an hourly wage to the filer. A person can compare actual experience with those lines without pretending that the national average has somehow measured a specific Saturday.

The broader scale is much larger. The active OIRA package for the individual income-tax collection lists 170.1 million annual responses, 1.948 billion annual burden hours, and $49.76 billion in annual cost burden. That collection includes Form 1040 and a long list of associated forms. Its response total is not a count of 170.1 million people completing one ordinary return, and dividing the aggregate hours by responses would manufacture a personal estimate from unlike filings.

The figures do establish that the federal system already recognizes compliance time and cash cost as formal burden. The hours are not a metaphor added by a critic. They are part of the government’s own information-collection record.

How an average like this gets made

IRS Publication 5743 describes a taxpayer-centered model built from recurring burden surveys. The surveys ask about recordkeeping, planning, gathering materials, completing and submitting the return, and out-of-pocket costs. Samples are separated by preparation method and return complexity, then weighted to represent the filing population for the surveyed year. Survey results are combined with administrative data to estimate later filing years.

This is sturdier than taking the number of forms, guessing a completion time for each one, and calling the multiplication a national burden. The method also has edges. A modeled population average will not reproduce the particular evening when a document is missing, a dependent rule is unclear, software rejects an entry, or a life event turns last year’s familiar process into a different return.

The IRS warns that its reported figures are national averages and do not describe a typical case. Most taxpayers fall below the overall average, while return complexity and preparation method create wide variation. That warning does not make the estimate useless; it tells us what not to do with it. Eight hours should not become a deadline, a customer-service guarantee, or a claim about the person in the middle of the distribution.

The work can move without disappearing

Some filing burden is reduced before an individual ever opens the return. A Form W-2 can spare the worker from keeping a separate tax record for the same wages, although the reporting work still exists for the employer. Software and paid preparation can import data, ask structured questions, perform calculations, and check for errors. Those services may trade personal time for out-of-pocket cost rather than eliminate the task entirely.

Seen this way, tax preparation is not a single handoff from the IRS to the taxpayer. Work is distributed among the filer, employers, financial institutions, software systems, volunteer programs, and paid preparers. The IRS estimates illuminate part of that arrangement but do not show that every hour is avoidable or that one preparation method is best for every return. They do make it harder to keep talking as if the return simply appears when the correct numbers are typed into the final boxes.

The countercase matters. Income, deductions, credits, and payments determine a legal liability, and some claimed benefits require supporting facts. A shorter form can push work backward into recordkeeping or sideways into third-party reporting. An imported field can save time while creating a good reason to check that the imported number is right. Electronic preparation also reduces arithmetic errors, which can prevent a later round of notices and corrections. The useful challenge is not “paperwork bad.” It is whether the work is necessary, understandable, proportionate, and assigned to the people or systems able to do it reliably.

The line where the estimate stops

The Form 1040 burden table expressly excludes post-filing activity. GAO’s taxpayer-experience work explains why that boundary is substantial. After filing, a person may receive a notice, encounter a math error or identity issue, ask about a refund, deal with an unpaid balance, amend a return, send correspondence, make a call, or visit an office. Those paths can require several interactions over time, but none belongs inside the original eight-hour estimate.

State and local returns also sit outside the table. So do the tax paid, refund received, any assigned dollar value for the filer’s time, the reporting costs carried by employers and financial institutions, and consequences that arise after filing. Leaving those lines blank may feel unsatisfying, but it is more accurate than building an impressive total from measures that describe different people, stages, and obligations.

Make a receipt that fits the work

A Time Tax Receipt can stay simple. During filing, keep separate lines for records, planning, completion and submission, and other pre-filing work. Track actual time if doing so is useful, but keep cash preparation cost on its own line and tax owed or refunded on another. If a notice or account problem arrives later, begin a post-filing receipt instead of pretending that the national eight-hour average predicted it.

The point is not to turn a reader into a compliance clerk for their own annoyance. It is to make the distribution of work legible. The tax result gets the bold type because it settles the account. The quieter total in the back of the instructions shows what people and systems had to supply before that account could be settled at all.

Evidence boundary

The filing estimates, burden categories, information-collection totals, methodology, and post-filing boundary come from IRS, OIRA, and GAO records. The description of work moving among filers, information issuers, software, and preparers is bent.WTF interpretation. The report does not establish that all filing burden is avoidable, value each hour in dollars, or offer tax advice.

Continue through the record

Keep the source record beside the claim.

The Library keeps definitions, exhibits, caveats, and related work close enough to check.

Start with an active file. Open the exhibits when a claim does real work.

Open the Library